Passive vs Active Management: Merits and Considerations

Investing is a crucial aspect of building wealth and securing financial stability. However, one of the most significant decisions investors face is choosing between passive and active investment strategies. Both approaches have their merits and drawbacks, and understanding these can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your financial goals and risk tolerance

Passive Management

Proponents of passive management subscribe to the semi-strong and strong forms of the Efficient Market Hypothesis, i.e. it's impossible to consistently beat the market over the long-term. Since it's impossible to beat the market, investors are better off by using low-cost, passive strategies.

‍

The idea behind passive investing is to track an index (or multiple indices) of stocks, such as the S&P 500. The easiest way to do this is to buy passive funds, such as ETFs and/or mutual funds. In doing so, investors are able to diversify away unsystematic risk. In other words, their portfolios become less affected by the movements of individual stocks, and, instead, investors generate returns by participating in the general growth of corporate earnings over time.

‍

Passive investing certainly has its merits. A study done by Morningstar found that only 23% of active managers were able to outperform their passive peers over a 10-year period starting in June 2009. This means that the majority of investors can and should use passive strategies because they will not be able to consistently beat the market through active strategies.

‍

Advantages of Passive Investing

‍

1. Lower Costs: Passive funds typically have lower expense ratios compared to actively managed funds because they require less management and trading.
2. Simplicity: Passive investing is straightforward. Investors can simply buy an index fund or ETF and hold it for the long term.
3. Tax Efficiency: Due to lower turnover rates, passive funds often generate fewer capital gains, resulting in lower tax liabilities for investors.
4. Market Performance: By tracking a market index, passive funds generally perform in line with the market, providing steady returns over time.

‍

Disadvantages of Passive Investing

1. Limited Flexibility: Passive funds are designed to follow an index, so they cannot take advantage of market opportunities or avoid downturns.
2. Average Returns: Since passive funds aim to match the market, they will not outperform it. Investors seeking higher returns may find this approach limiting.
3. Market Risk: Passive investors are fully exposed to market risk, meaning their investments will rise and fall with the market.

‍

Active Management

Proponents of active management believe that the markets can be beat through more hands-on strategies. Active managers typically use sophisticated strategies (including tactical trading, hedging, shorting, and leverage) in an attempt to outperform an index.

‍

Tactical trading involves timing trades to the market. In other words, investors are trying to "buy low and sell high." Investors will often also reallocate money from overbought stocks to ones that they consider oversold. Tactical trading has many potential benefits, but also a high degree of risk if the investor's timing is wrong.

‍

Hedging involves making an investment that is designed to reduce the risk of another investment. For example, an investor might buy a put option designed to hedge against losses in the long stock position. There are many ways to hedge, but shorting is one of the most common ways to do so.

‍

Shorting (or short-selling) is when an investor bets that a stock will decline in value. The process involves an investor borrowing a stock from a broker, selling that stock on the open market, then buying it back to return to the broker at a later point in time. Here, the investor will benefit if the stock declines in value. Active managers will often use shorting to hedge their portfolio and also to bet that stocks and/or the market will decline.

‍

Leverage (or margin) is when an investor borrows money to buy/sell stocks. Leverage can be very rewarding but also very dangerous because it amplifies the movements of an investor's portfolio, whether up or down.

‍

Advantages of Active Investing

‍

1. Potential for Higher Returns: Active managers aim to outperform the market by selecting undervalued securities or timing market movements.
2. Flexibility: Active managers can adjust their portfolios in response to market conditions, economic trends, or company-specific events.
3. Risk Management: Active strategies can include various risk management techniques, such as hedging or diversifying across different asset classes.

‍

Disadvantages of Active Investing

‍

1. Higher Costs: Active funds typically have higher expense ratios due to the costs associated with research, trading, and management.
2. Tax Implications: Frequent trading can result in higher capital gains taxes for investors.
3. Performance Variability: Not all active managers can consistently outperform the market. In fact, many fail to do so over the long term.

‍

‍

So What?

So what does all of this mean for you? Should you go with passive management or active management? Well, the answer is not that simple. Most investors would benefit from a bit of both.

‍

Passive management is by far the most popular type of management by AUM. Passive managers have also largely outperformed active managers. Passive management has several benefits, including low fees, low taxes (due to a low amount of trades), and simplicity. On the other hand, passive management is not without its faults either. Passive strategies rarely, if ever, outperform the market on both an absolute and risk-adjusted basis. Passive strategies also result in large drawdowns during periods of market weakness (e.g. 2008 recession, COVID-19).

‍

Active management is much harder to get right than passive management. If you are interested in active management, it's very important to identify which managers will be able to consistently beat the market. Active managers will typically charge significantly higher fees than their passive counterparts because there is much more work involved. Active strategies also commonly generate higher taxes than passive strategies because of the larger amount of trades being made. However, these additional expenses are worth it if the manager is good. Top managers are able to outperform the market, generate consistent, risk-adjusted returns across all market environments, and limit drawdowns during bad years.

‍

Just like anything else in life, it's best not to put all your eggs in one basket. Investors should seek to diversify their portfolios as much as possible. You've heard about diversifying your holdings, but you can and should also diversify your strategies. This is why you should use a mix of both passive management and active management.

‍

What about alphaAI?

‍

In any investment endeavor, the key to success lies in making informed decisions. Whether you're building a recession-resistant portfolio, diversifying your assets, or simply exploring new opportunities, your journey should be guided by knowledge and insight. At alphaAI, we are dedicated to helping you invest intelligently with AI-powered strategies. Our robo advisor adapts to market shifts, offering dynamic wealth management tailored to your risk level and portfolio preferences. We're your trusted partner in the complex world of finance, working with you to make smarter investments and pursue your financial goals with confidence. Your journey to financial success begins here, with alphaAI by your side.